Lawyers' conduct in Ramjanambhoomi hearing shameful, says CJI



New Delhi, Dec 7 (IANS) Chief Justice of India Dipak Misra on Thursday lamented the conduct of certain senior lawyers during the hearing in the Ramjanambhoomi-Babri Masjid dispute case in the Supreme Court, dubbing it "shameful".



Senior lawyers Kapil Sibal, Rajeev Dhavan and Dushant Dave had threatened to leave on Tuesday after the apex court asked senior counsel C.S. Vaidyanathan to commence arguments in the Ayodhya case.



"What happened yesterday (Wednesday) was shameful. What happened day before yesterday (Tuesday) was extremely shameful," said Chief Justice Misra, who heads the Constitution Bench.



"Unfortunately, a small group of lawyers think they can raise their voice. We make it clear that raising of voice will not be tolerated. Raising of voice only shows your (lawyers) inadequacy and incompetence," he said.



Reminding the Bar of its traditions, he said: "It is not the tradition of the Bar. If the Bar does not regulate itself, we will compel it to regulate itself." 



Sibal, Dhavan and Dave had sought deferment of the Ramjanambhoomi case hearing till after the 2019 general elections but the Supreme Court had asked Vaidyanathan -- appearing for deity Ramlala -- to commence arguments. The case was later deferred to February 8.



Recording the incident during the hearing of Ayodhya matter on December 5 when Sibal, Dhavan and Dave had sought the leave of the court to recuse themselves from proceedings with arguments, the court in its Tuesday's order had described it "shocking and surprising".



"We declined the said permission and we must say, that they accepted. If we permit ourselves to say so, the submission was shocking and surprising and when we proceeded to record so, prayer was made not to do so and we, accepting the fervent request made by the counsel, refrain from recording so," the court had said in its December 5 order on Ramjanmabhoomi-Babri Masjid disputed site title suit hearing.



On Wednesday, the Chief Justice took exception to Dhavan telling the constitution bench that they have narrowed down the scope of the hearing by limiting it to proviso 4 of the Article 239AA - spelling special powers for Delhi, a view not supported by other lawyers appearing for the Delhi government.



Apparently displeased over the submission, the Chief Justice said: "This is unfair, uncalled for and unwarranted argument. You can't say something and attribute it to us."



At this juncture, the bench decided to rise with court ushers moving in to escort the judges. But then hearing resumed.



At the end of the hearing, Dhavan, in his concluding remarks, told the court that he would not mind any judgment in a case of the tussle between the Central and the Delhi governments on the powers to administer Delhi, which was objected to by senior counsel Indira Jaising.



The Chief Justice appreciated Jaising for telling Dhavan that he can't be presumptive about the judgment.



The Chief Justice's remarks on Thursday came on the commencement of hearing in the case when senior counsel Gopal Subramanium, in order to express the legal fraternity's concerns, said they too were "conservative" in practicing the Bar's traditions and upholding the court's majesty.

IANS

 

Related news

Don’t Miss

Hills under white cover..Chilly weather in North India
Economic shock for PM Modi..Price rise at 15-month HIGH
Aggressive Rahul says BJP is scared, Cong will win Gujarat
Modi is using seaplane to run away from real issues in Gujarat
Modi cracks whip, criminal netas will be JAILED soon
Semi nude body of woman start-up founder shocks Mumbai
'PM Modi eats imported mushroom worth Rs 400000 daily to get fair skin'
PM Modi's seaplane campaign stunt stuns Congress
Rahul meets Maa Sonia first time as Congress Prez..Emotional moment
Confident Rahul tweets in Gujarati, says Thank You Gujarat
First Tesla arrives in India..Two businessmen 'FIGHT" for it!
Big worry for PM Modi..Industrial output falls by 50%
Hardik, Congress make fun of Modi's 'Hawa Hawai' seaplane campaign
Anushka's wedding ring was costlier than the rent of their wedding venue
Video: Virat kisses emotional Anushka when she cried in her 'Bidaai'
10 Points: What Rahul said about Modi on last day of Gujarat campaign
Video: Anushka Sharma crying bitterly in her 'Bidaai' will melt your heart
Thalaiva Birthday: Rajinikanth dons a stylish look on Kaalaa poster
Father-in-law guilty in Tamil Nadu Dalit youth honour killing
Shocking... Taapsee reveals a big secret about her upcoming movie!
Inside Pictures of Kohli-Anushka wedding
Rahul Gandhi to host dinner as President of Congress on Dec 17
Tata Motors planning to increase prices of passenger vehicles
WOW.. Sridevi reacts to Jahnvi's debut and says this!
WOW... this new feature on Whatsapp is all you ever wanted!
Video: Virat Kohli singing for Anushka at cocktail party will give relationship goals
Rahul roars: Targets PM Narendra Modi in Gujarat, says Congress is winning
When Salman Khan saved Anushka-Virat relationship
Video: Crowds cheer as PM Modi goes to Ambaji by road
Three soldiers missing in avalanche in Kashmir

Most Recent






Most Popular